The Power of Positive Thinking by Norman Vincent Peale Book Review
The Power of Positive Thinking by Norman Vincent Peale is a 17-chapter self help book first published in October 1952 by Prentice Hall and reissued in paperback by Touchstone in 2003. It teaches that a person's mental state sets the terms for what they attempt, and it hands the reader drills for changing that state: spoken affirmations, a daily mind emptying practice, and a formula Peale calls prayerize, picturize, actualize. Kevin Trudeau's own commentary traces the modern positive thinking movement back to this book. Read it if you want the most concrete set of practical techniques anyone in this genre ever printed. Skip it if the Christian framing is a barrier, or if you need the case histories to be checkable.
As an Amazon Associate, KevinTrudeau.com earns from qualifying purchases. This does not change the price you pay.
One thing to settle first. This is a religious book sold for seventy years as a general one, and knowing that changes what you take from it.
What The Power of Positive Thinking Actually Teaches
Peale argues that a mind loaded with negative thoughts produces a small life, that the loading is a habit rather than a fact about the person, and that it answers to daily practice. Everything else is a technique or one of the stories about somebody who used it. His introduction states the aim without hedging: "This book teaches applied Christianity; a simple yet scientific system of practical techniques of successful living that works." That sentence carries the book's strength and the charge against it at once.
Self Doubt Is the Target
Chapter one opens with an order rather than an argument. "BELIEVE IN YOURSELF! Have faith in your abilities!" Peale names the enemy on the same page: "the malady popularly called the inferiority complex," which he calls "another term for deep and profound self doubt." His stated cure is to fill the mind with faith until the doubt has no room left. That one target explains the shape of the book. Peale is not writing about goal setting, money or strategy. He is writing about the voice that tells somebody not to bother trying, and about the self-confidence he believes overcomes it.
The Ten Rules at the End of Chapter One
Most summaries stop at the slogan. The content is a numbered drill: "ten simple, workable rules for overcoming inadequacy attitudes and learning to practice faith." Several are unusually specific.
- Rule one. "Stamp indelibly on your mind a mental picture of yourself as succeeding," and never let the image fade.
- Rule two. When a negative thought arrives, "deliberately voice a positive thought to cancel it out."
- Rule three. Depreciate every so-called obstacle rather than inflate obstacles with fear.
- Rule eight. "Make a true estimate of your own ability, then raise it 10 percent."
- Rule six. See "a competent counselor" to learn where the feelings of inferiority and self doubt began, because "self-knowledge leads to a cure."
Flag rule six. It complicates this book's most famous criticism.
Prayerize, Picturize, Actualize
Peale's named formula sits in chapter four. "The formula is (1) PRAYERIZE, (2) PICTURIZE, (3) ACTUALIZE." Prayerize means talking problems over with God daily in plain language, treating him, in Peale's telling, as "a partner, as a close associate." Picturize means holding one clear image of the outcome. Actualize means surrendering that picture and working hard toward it anyway. Readers who know the four steps in Kevin Trudeau's manifestation formula will recognize the skeleton. Peale published his version in 1952.
One honest note. Peale does not claim the formula as his own. He credits it to an unnamed friend, "a man who has a creative and unique mind." That habit of sourcing a method to somebody the reader cannot check runs through the book.
Affirmations and the Mind Emptying Habit
Rule seven has the reader repeat "I can do all things through Christ which strengtheneth me" ten times each day, out loud where possible. Peale prescribes scripture as a set of affirmations on a fixed count, and he means the count literally. The second practice is emptying the mind. "I recommend a mind-emptying at least twice a day, more often if necessary. Definitely practice emptying your mind of fears, hates, insecurities, regrets, and guilt feelings." Clear the room, then furnish it. That order separates the book from a pep talk.
How Peale's Book Is Organized
Seventeen chapters, in this order: Believe in Yourself; A Peaceful Mind Generates Power; How to Have Constant Energy; Try Prayer Power; How to Create Your Own Happiness; Stop Fuming and Fretting; Expect the Best and Get It; Don't Believe in Defeat; How to Break the Worry Habit; Power to Solve Personal Problems; How to Use Faith in Healing; When Vitality Sags, Try This; Inflow of New Thoughts Can Remake You; Relax for Easy Power; How to Get People to Like You; Prescription for Heartache; and How to Draw upon That Higher Power.
One complaint per chapter. Worry gets a chapter. Anger gets a chapter. Being disliked gets a chapter. Peale ran a large congregation in New York and heard the same problems in a loop, and the contents page reads like the list he kept.
Chapter eleven is titled "How to Use Faith in Healing." It exists, and this review takes no position on its contents. Nothing here is health, medical or treatment guidance of any kind. Read that chapter as one minister's opinion from 1952.
The Power of Positive Thinking at a Glance
| Detail | What the record shows |
|---|---|
| Author | Norman Vincent Peale, American clergyman, born May 31, 1898 in Bowersville, Ohio, died December 24, 1993 |
| First published | October 1952, by Prentice Hall |
| Edition linked here | Touchstone paperback reissue, 2003, ISBN 9780743234801 |
| Chapters | 17 |
| Stated aim | "Applied Christianity; a simple yet scientific system of practical techniques of successful living" |
| Named formula | Prayerize, picturize, actualize |
| Named drills | Ten rules closing chapter one; spoken affirmations repeated ten times daily; mind emptying twice a day |
| Stated target | The inferiority complex, which Peale defines as deep and profound self doubt |
| Bestseller run | 186 weeks on the New York Times list, 48 of them at number one in non-fiction, according to Wikipedia |
| Reach | More than 5 million copies and over 40 languages, according to Wikipedia |
| Our rating | 3.0 out of 5 |
Norman Vincent Peale, the Minister Behind the Book
Norman Vincent Peale was a working pastor, not a psychologist, and the book makes more sense once that is clear. Born in Bowersville, Ohio in 1898, he took degrees at Ohio Wesleyan University and Boston University School of Theology and was ordained in 1922. He served as a Methodist minister until 1932, then moved to the Reformed Church in America and took the pulpit at Marble Collegiate Church in New York City, where he stayed until 1984. About 200 people attended when he arrived. The congregation grew into the thousands.
Two other pieces of his record matter here. In 1937 he co-founded the American Foundation of Religion and Psychiatry with the psychoanalyst Smiley Blanton, and the two wrote books together. In 1945 he co-founded the magazine Guideposts with his wife Ruth and Raymond Thornburg. He spent decades working between religion and clinical psychology.
Then came the detail that should stay with you. When Peale published this book in 1952, Blanton, his psychiatric collaborator of fifteen years, declined to endorse it. Donald Capps documented that in the Journal of Religion and Health in 2009. A co-author stepping back tells you something a sales figure cannot.
Common Criticisms of The Power of Positive Thinking
This book has one of the longest and best documented critical records in the genre, much of it collected on Wikipedia's page for The Power of Positive Thinking. Here is what the critics said, with names attached.
The case histories cannot be checked
Peale's evidence is anecdote, and the anecdotes are anonymous. The reader meets a business executive, a man described only as an alcoholic, and "a famous trapeze artist" who freezes on the high bar. None has a name. Peale called his system scientific, then supplied nothing a reader could verify.
The self-hypnosis charge
The psychiatrist R.C. Murphy reviewed the book in The Nation on May 7, 1955 and wrote that "self-knowledge, in Mr. Peale's understanding, is unequivocally bad; self-hypnosis is good." The psychologist Albert Ellis, who founded rational emotive behavior therapy, compared Peale's methods to the suggestion techniques of Emile Coue and said the teachings "lead to failure and disillusionment."
Here an honest review has to complicate the story. Murphy's line gets quoted constantly, and rule six says the opposite: see a competent counselor, learn where your inferiority and self doubt began, and understand that self-knowledge leads to a cure. Peale wrote that in 1952. The charge lands on the book's overall drift. It does not survive contact with that page.
The theological objection
Peale's fiercest critics were not psychologists. They were other Christians. The theologian Reinhold Niebuhr said of the movement Peale led, "This new cult is dangerous. Anything which corrupts the Gospel hurts Christianity. And it hurts people too," in William Peters's Redbook article of September 1955. The Episcopal theologian John M. Krumm called the teachings heretical in his 1961 book Modern Heresies, on the grounds that they put human technique where the purpose of God should be. Edmund Fuller, then book review editor of Episcopal Churchnews, wrote in the Saturday Review in March 1957 that Peale offered "easy comforts, easy solutions." Adlai Stevenson compressed it all into one line in the 1952 presidential campaign: "I find the Apostle Paul appealing and the Apostle Peale appalling."
The word "scientific"
William Lee Miller, later of the University of Virginia, wrote a 1955 essay titled "Some Negative Thinking About Norman Vincent Peale" and concluded that Peale's books "are hard on the truth." Decades on, the psychologist Martin Seligman, a past president of the American Psychological Association, described positive thinking as an attempt to believe upbeat statements "in the absence of evidence."
The criticisms at a glance
| What the book claims | The objection | Who made it |
|---|---|---|
| The techniques are proven by case histories | The cases are anonymous and unverifiable | A recurring criticism, and visible on the page |
| Repeated affirmations rebuild the mind | Closer to self-hypnosis than to self-knowledge | Psychiatrist R.C. Murphy, The Nation, May 7, 1955 |
| The method works for anyone who applies it | Can end in failure and disillusionment | Psychologist Albert Ellis |
| This is applied Christianity | "This new cult is dangerous" | Theologian Reinhold Niebuhr, quoted by William Peters, Redbook, September 1955 |
| God supplies power on request | Heretical; technique replaces the purpose of God | John M. Krumm, Modern Heresies, 1961 |
| The book solves everyday problems | "Easy comforts, easy solutions" | Edmund Fuller, Saturday Review, March 1957 |
| A simple yet scientific system | The books "are hard on the truth" | William Lee Miller, 1955 |
| Believing hard enough changes outcomes | Upbeat statements held in the absence of evidence | Psychologist Martin Seligman |
Key Lessons From The Power of Positive Thinking
- Peale teaches that self doubt, not circumstance, is the first obstacle to remove.
- The ten rules closing chapter one are the working core of the book.
- His named formula is prayerize, picturize, actualize.
- Affirmations are meant to be spoken aloud on a fixed daily count, not read once.
- Mind emptying comes before mind filling, twice a day in his instruction.
- The Christian framing is not decoration; it supplies the affirmations.
- The evidence is anecdotal and anonymous, and readers should treat it that way.
Why Kevin Trudeau Points Readers Toward Peale, and Where He Departs
The Power of Positive Thinking sits at number 23 on the recommended reading list published by the Official Kevin Trudeau Fan Club, which describes the list as coming directly from Kevin Trudeau. The book is on the shelf, so the interesting question is what Trudeau does with it.
His position is not that Peale was wrong. It is that positive thinking is one ingredient rather than the whole recipe. That argument has its own two articles here, and this review is not the place to relitigate it: read why positive thinking does not work on its own, according to Kevin Trudeau, and Trudeau's longer argument that positive thinking is not enough. This page is about the book.
The exact point of collision is where Peale's drill runs out. Peale's answer to a negative thought is rule two: voice a positive thought to cancel it. Trudeau's claim is that some of those thoughts are standing programs rather than passing weather, and he calls them counterintentions. In his telling a person can voice the positive statement ten times a day for a year and get nothing, because it is spoken over beliefs that never agreed to it. Peale offers no diagnostic there. His prescription is more repetition.
Trudeau's other lever is the Teachability Index, willingness to learn multiplied by willingness to change. Run this book through it and the mixed reports make sense. Peale is easy to be willing to learn from: warm, plain, short chapters, and he asks nothing uncomfortable of you. Whether the reader then runs the drill for months is the half that decides the result.
Where It Sits Next to the Global Information Network
Trudeau founded the Global Information Network in 2009 as a private membership club built around his claim that the most useful knowledge about wealth and success was kept out of general circulation. His teachings are arranged as a sequence rather than a single insight, and the pieces here include Your Wish Is Your Command and the Training Balance Scale, which argues that most of the work is internal.
Peale would have recognized that idea. The difference is what each man says the internal work consists of. For Peale it is faith, repetition and prayer. For Trudeau it is frequency, repetition and the removal of counterintentions. Same instruction to look inward, different account of what you find there.
For the same era without the religious framing, see Success Through a Positive Mental Attitude by Napoleon Hill and What to Say When You Talk to Yourself by Shad Helmstetter.
Who Should Read The Power of Positive Thinking and Who Should Skip It
Read it if you want the drills rather than the theory. Very few books here tell you how many times a day to do the thing. This one does. Read it if you are a Christian reader, because the framing that pushes other people away is the framing that works for you. Read it if you want the source code for what came later, since Peale published the picture-and-repeat method in 1952 and half the genre has restated it since.
Skip it if you want evidence, since the case histories are anonymous and the book asks a great deal on trust. Skip it if the religious content is a wall for you, because it is not removable. Skip it if you have worked through Psycho-Cybernetics, which covers self-image with a clinician's care.
One caution the period critics were right about. This book was written for ordinary discouragement: the flat week, the lost nerve, the job you are afraid to ask for. Peale's rule six sends a struggling reader to a counselor, and that rule deserves as much circulation as his slogan got.
Our rating: 3.0 out of 5. High marks for specificity, durability, and techniques a reader can actually run. Real deductions for the anonymous evidence, for the word "scientific" doing work it cannot support, and for leaving no page at all for the reader who runs the drill honestly and gets nothing.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is The Power of Positive Thinking by Norman Vincent Peale worth reading?
Yes, with one condition. It is worth reading for the drills, which are more specific than almost anything else in the genre: the ten rules at the end of chapter one, spoken affirmations on a daily count, and the prayerize, picturize, actualize formula. It is worth much less if you need checkable evidence, since the case histories are anonymous throughout.
What is the main message of The Power of Positive Thinking?
Peale argues that self doubt, which he calls the inferiority complex, is the first obstacle between a person and what they want. His claim is that the habit of negative thinking can be replaced through deliberate daily practice, and that faith supplies the material for the replacement. Chapter one states it as an order: believe in yourself, have faith in your abilities.
What are the practical techniques in The Power of Positive Thinking?
Four stand out. The ten rules closing chapter one, including holding a mental image of yourself succeeding and voicing a positive thought to cancel each negative one. Spoken affirmations repeated ten times a day. A mind emptying practice done at least twice daily. And Peale's named formula: prayerize, picturize, actualize.
Is The Power of Positive Thinking a religious book?
Yes, and openly so. Peale's introduction calls it applied Christianity. Most of the affirmations he prescribes are lines of scripture, prayer is the subject of a full chapter, and the source of power the book keeps pointing to is God. A reader who wants the techniques without the religion will be editing on every page.
How is The Power of Positive Thinking organized?
Seventeen chapters, each aimed at one everyday problem. Worry, anger, low energy, defeat, heartache and being disliked each get a chapter of their own. The chapters are short and self contained, so the book reads well in pieces. The working core arrives early, in chapter one and chapter four.
What are the main criticisms of The Power of Positive Thinking?
Four recur. The case histories are anonymous and unverifiable. Psychiatrist R.C. Murphy wrote in The Nation in May 1955 that Peale treated self-hypnosis as good and self-knowledge as bad. Theologians including Reinhold Niebuhr and John M. Krumm objected that the book corrupts Christian teaching. And William Lee Miller wrote in 1955 that Peale's books "are hard on the truth."
Did Norman Vincent Peale have a background in psychology?
No. Peale was a clergyman, ordained in 1922, with degrees from Ohio Wesleyan University and Boston University School of Theology. He worked alongside psychiatry rather than inside it, co-founding the American Foundation of Religion and Psychiatry in 1937 with the psychoanalyst Smiley Blanton. Blanton declined to endorse this book when it appeared in 1952.
Does Kevin Trudeau agree with The Power of Positive Thinking?
Partly. The book appears on the recommended reading list published by the Official Kevin Trudeau Fan Club, so Trudeau points people to it. His stated position is that positive thinking is one ingredient rather than the whole method, and that repeating a positive statement over an opposing subconscious belief produces nothing.
The Power of Positive Thinking by Norman Vincent Peale Book Review: The Short Version
Seventeen chapters, one target, more concrete instruction than the genre usually offers. Peale names the enemy as self doubt, then prescribes ten rules, a spoken affirmation ten times a day, a twice-daily mind emptying, and the formula prayerize, picturize, actualize. The Christian framing is permanent and the evidence is anonymous, which is why psychiatrists, psychologists and theologians lined up against it in the 1950s. Read it for the drills, not for proof. If you run them and nothing moves, that is where Trudeau's material asks a different question.